More HMRC caseworkers, more SDLT scrutiny: what it means for conveyancers

HMRC is in the middle of one of the largest recruitment drives in its recent history. Since the Autumn Budget 2024 the government has committed well over a billion pounds to putting thousands of additional compliance staff to work, with a clear instruction to close the tax gap and bring in more revenue. For conveyancing firms that file Stamp Duty Land Tax returns every week, that should prompt a simple question. When those new caseworkers start looking at property transactions, will your files stand up?

The numbers behind the drive

At the Autumn Budget 2024 the government announced £1.4 billion over five years to recruit 5,000 additional HMRC compliance staff, with a target of raising £2.7 billion a year in extra revenue by 2029/30. A further 500 compliance roles followed in the Spring Statement 2025. The Autumn Budget 2025 went further again, setting out plans for 5,500 new compliance caseworkers to be recruited and trained by 2030/31 alongside 2,400 additional debt management staff.

This is not a plan that exists only on paper. HMRC’s own performance update, published in August 2026, confirmed that more than 2,400 new compliance colleagues have joined since the Autumn Budget 2024, including over 250 between April and June 2026 alone. Roughly half of the planned headcount is already in post and the rest is on its way.

At the same time HMRC is investing heavily in data. The government has consulted on making better use of third party data to automate checks and it has been open about using AI and advanced analytics across its compliance work. More people combined with better tools means more returns can be examined, more quickly, with fewer transactions slipping through unnoticed.

Perhaps the most telling detail is where HMRC wants that extra effort to land. In its latest performance update it set an aim for at least a quarter of its compliance yield to come from work that stops non compliance before it happens, rather than correcting it afterwards. In other words, HMRC wants returns to be right first time and it is building the capacity to check whether they are.

Why SDLT is firmly in scope

SDLT is a self assessed tax. The buyer is legally liable, but in practice the return is almost always prepared and filed by the conveyancer. Every return is effectively a series of judgements. Which rates apply? Are the higher rates for additional dwellings triggered? Is the property genuinely residential or is it mixed use? Is a relief available? Are any transactions linked? Each of those judgements is a point that HMRC can test.

HMRC has spent years building expertise in exactly these areas. It has a strong record of challenging questionable claims at tribunal, particularly speculative mixed use arguments where the slightest suggestion of a non residential element is used to justify lower rates. That experience has not gone anywhere. With more caseworkers available, the resource intensive work of opening enquiries and pursuing them through the tribunal becomes far easier to sustain.

Tax specialists are also reporting changes in how HMRC investigates. Inspectors are said to be more willing to run parallel investigations into a business and its directors at the same time and to review several years of records rather than a single period. Property transactions sit naturally within that wider picture. A purchase made by a company, a director or a family trust can easily become part of an enquiry that started somewhere else entirely.

How far back HMRC can look

HMRC normally has nine months from the filing date to open an enquiry into an SDLT return. Beyond that window, its discovery powers allow it to raise an assessment up to four years after the transaction as standard, six years where an inaccuracy was careless and up to twenty years where it was deliberate. Penalties for a careless inaccuracy can reach 30% of the additional tax due, with interest on top.

Put simply, a return filed this week could be examined by a caseworker HMRC has not yet hired. The standard it will be judged against is not how busy the team was on the day it was submitted, but whether the calculation was correct and properly supported.

Where the risk lands for conveyancers

When HMRC challenges a return, the immediate bill goes to the buyer. The consequences rarely stop there. A client facing additional tax, interest and possibly penalties will want to know why the return was wrong and who advised them. The courts have long recognised that a solicitor’s duty can extend to the tax consequences of a transaction, with Hurlingham Estates v Wilde the classic example. Later cases such as Minkin v Landsberg show how much depends on the scope of the retainer and on what was actually agreed with the client.

For a firm, a challenged return can quickly turn into a complaint, a notification to professional indemnity insurers and a potential claim, not to mention the damage to a client relationship that may have taken years to build. Multiply that across a busy residential caseload and the exposure becomes significant.

HMRC has also tightened its grip on those who act for taxpayers. In May 2026 it introduced a single registration process requiring advisers to meet minimum standards before dealing with HMRC on behalf of their clients. The direction of travel is clear. HMRC expects the people who interact with it on a taxpayer’s behalf to be accountable for what they submit.

What firms can do now

Start early. The facts that drive an SDLT calculation, such as whether the buyer owns other property, whether they are replacing a main residence and how the property will be used, are far easier to establish at the start of a matter than in the days before completion. Treating SDLT as part of the transaction from the outset reduces the risk of a rushed judgement.

Record the reasoning. If HMRC opens an enquiry, the strongest defence is a file that shows what information was gathered, what questions were asked and why a particular rate or relief was applied. A calculation without an audit trail is much harder to defend.

Be cautious with aggressive positions. Arguments for mixed use treatment or other reliefs should rest on genuine facts, not on a minor feature stretched to fit. HMRC has repeatedly shown it will challenge weak claims and it now has more people to do so.

Be clear about the retainer. Make sure the client understands what SDLT advice is and is not covered, record the advice given and flag where specialist input is needed.

Apply a consistent process. Risk often comes from inconsistency, where different fee earners approach similar transactions in different ways. A single, reliable process across the firm protects both clients and the business.

How Compass helps

Compass is a specialist SDLT calculation and submission platform built for conveyancing firms. Through Compass Concierge we become involved early in the transaction, stay in touch throughout and deal with home movers directly. This means the facts behind each calculation are captured properly and the reasoning is recorded from the start. That gives firms a clear, consistent position on every matter, whatever HMRC asks later.

Our commercial model is equally straightforward. Compass charges a flat fee per matter regardless of value, complexity or structure, on a pay as you go basis with no subscription, contract or minimum volumes. We also integrate with the case management and search platforms firms already use and we will build an integration with any system a client relies on.

The bottom line

HMRC is spending heavily to look harder at tax returns of every kind and SDLT is no exception. The extra caseworkers are already arriving and more are on the way. The firms that will feel the least impact are those whose returns are right first time and whose files show exactly why. If you would like to understand how your current SDLT process would stand up to closer scrutiny, the Compass team would be glad to talk it through.

To find out more about Compass book a no obligation meeting here.